Revolutions are "invisible, technical, legal” - one can have the benefits of revolution without actually going through one. Review of Kim Stanley Robinson’s The Ministry for the Future (Orbit, 2020). Hell, write a sequel to this book that tells the story of the Ministry’s black ops wing - show us what it means to blow up aircraft, assassinate the heads of corporations and steal the wealth of billionaires. If you’re a young reader, the same age I was when first reading Robinson’s works, it’s a great introduction to post-capitalist ideas. It would be fair to say that Robinson’s works - especially the Mars Trilogy and the earlier Three Californias trilogy - had a formative effect on me and my politics growing up. The head of the Ministry, Mary Murphy, spends most of her time trying to convince corporations of their responsibility to the earth, but it's a slow process. Not so in Kim Stanley Robinson’s latest book, The Ministry for the Future. A large amount of the first half of the book takes place over ridiculously priced cocktails in Swiss bars [accurate]. Climate lukewarmers may be tempted to interpret this upbeat summary as support for their technological optimism. Its main character - Mary Murphy, an ex-Irish Foreign Minister tapped to head a new UN agency set up to save the world - is almost a stock liberal archetype, but over the course of the book’s 560 pages Robinson paints an affecting portrait of her as a human being. It soon became known as the Ministry for the Future, and this is its story. Realist but progressive. The Ministry for the Future is a novel by American science fiction writer Kim Stanley Robinson published in 2020. Respectability Politics and the Great Free Speech Panic of 2017, The "hereditarian left", if they exist, are just luck egalitarians and that's still not OK, Climate Change broke the neoliberal consensus, too, A 'Voice' for Indigenous Australians (Part 4): The Egalitarian Alternative and Conclusion, A 'Voice' for Indigenous Australians (Part 1): Setting the scene, Myths of the Old Order: The automation illusion (part two), Myths of the Old Order: The automation illusion (part one), What is Socialism? In The Ministry for the Future, Kim Stanley Robinson attempts to create a futurama exhibit of the next century that will take humanity through climate change. The book - without putting these words in the voice of any particular character - rejects the idea that there are “totalizing solutions” to the world’s problems. Several years ago, our family went to a holiday season performance at a kids’ art space in downtown Vancouver. Chapter 99 is worth discussing in detail because it lays the thesis statement of this book out in detail. Privilege, Preference and #MeToo, Why I’m a radical feminist (but not THAT kind of radical feminist), The Signal is not the Strategy (It's OK to be hypocritical, Part 3), Myths of the Old Order: The Kirk/Spock Dialectic and Toxic Rationality, On Reputation: Or, how and why bad ideas need rebranding, The Left eats its children. More By and About This Author. Intriguingly, though, a core component of the transformation this book imagines is brought about by terror - by terrorist groups, and [spoilers] by state terror conducted by the Ministry itself - but we learn almost nothing about this shadowy war taking place in the background of the story. “Ministry for the Future” owes a lot to Robinson’s earlier works. ), The Omnivore's Dilemma Redux: Understanding Anti-Vaxxers. One in which we might just overcome the extraordinary challenges we face. Some reviews describe it as hard science fiction but this book - like the Mars trilogy before it - is more sociological than that. Robinson’s view of climate change is deeply personal, inescapably human and utterly horrifying. Robinson loves writing about non-Anglo-Saxon cultures, and while “Ministry for the Future” is overloaded with reverence for the Swiss [a portrait that, as someone who’s lived in Switzerland, I find a tad obsequious], like “Year of Rice and Salt” it’s the Indians who by-and-large save the world. So is gender. If so, comment below. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. It is a novel both immediate and impactful, desperate and hopeful in equal measure, and it is one of the most powerful and original books on climate change ever written. This … That said, I absolutely loathed his last novel, “Red Moon” (2018) - which was not a very good book about China, nor a good book about the moon, nor a good book about a revolution. His bumbling and his anger drive him to a failed kidnap attempt on Mary Murphy, head of the titular Ministry for the Future, a U.N. agency formed in 2025 to further the aims of the Paris Agreement. Established in 2025, the purpose of the new organization was simple: To advocate for the world’s future generations and to protect all living creatures, present and future. But it is a sober, realist take. The venue was also hosting an exhibit about children’s visions of the city one hundred years from then. It’s stunningly well written, and surprisingly affecting. Robinson has a lot of say about life, death, the planet and what it all means. The book is almost a paeon to central bankers, mirroring the obsessive search by some on the left for a magic policy solution that can be designed, implemented and measured by technocrats. Big moments in “Ministry for the Future”, the inflection points that shift the course of history away from disaster, take place in board rooms in Switzerland and Silicon Valley. His writing often reveals a strongly anti-capitalist bent, albeit shot through with a dose of California Ideology techno-libertarianism and environmentalism. In other words, this is book explicitly in the Utopian - rather than Marxist - socialist tradition. The Right digs up its dead. Have you read any of Kim Stanley Robinson other works, or any other books on climate change? "The People, No" by Thomas Frank, Review: “The Deficit Myth” by Stephanie Kelton, Book Review: “The Narrow Corridor” by Daron Acemoglu & James Robinson, Book Reviews: “The Dream of Reason” & “The Dream of Enlightenment” by Anthony Gottlieb, Book Review: "Darwin's Unfinished Symphony" by Kevin Laland, Book Review: "Neurotribes: The Legacy of Autism", Book Review: "Outliers: The Story of Success" by Malcolm Gladwell, Book Response: “Sapiens”, by Yuval Noah Harari (the takeaways), Book Response: “Moral Tribes” by Joshua Greene, Virtue and the aristocratic tendencies of liberalism. Who would I recommend this book to? Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Most of the illustrations were dystopian scenes from an early twenty-second-century future. In addition if you are interesting to read a Science Fiction book based on climate change, or you are interested in the subject and how the world may handle it, but do not want to read a dry textbook, then The Ministry For The Future, the latest book by Kim Stanley Robbinson, should be on your reading list. The only weakness for the general reader with this book is that Robinson is one of those writers that puts a lot of information in his books, which could be science, economic or any other subject that will fit in with the type of book he is writing. This is one of those books that I saw in NetGally and that I should request it, as I had read a number of Kim Stanley Robinson books before. I like them all. Power is an illusion - but laws are everything. The easyone is people who read and enjoyed, Kim Stanley Robinson, before as I feel he is back to his best with this one. The Ministry of The Future by Kim Stanley Robinson is a stark look at where the world could be heading in terms of climate change. Power doesn’t drive history - ideas do. From legendary science fiction author Kim Stanley Robinson comes a vision of climate change unlike any ever imagined. More MMT: inflation, inequality and punching left? That simple point is at the heart of my critique of The Ministry for the Future, a new work by Kim Stanley Robinson, which I've just finished. Robinson’s eco-socialist utopia is incomplete because he hand waves all that away - even while acknowledging that it’s necessary [in the world of the book] to get the outcome ultimately arrived at. Robinson’s latest novel, The Ministry for the Future, attempts to articulate the societal transformations, the collective shifts in thought, that will be necessary in order to confront and therefore change the shared future of the earth and all life therein. For example, the reason that ice glaciers are moving faster than normal because of climate change, was done in such a way that I wish my textbooks at school were written. Buy The Ministry for the Future by Robinson, Kim Stanley (ISBN: 9780356508832) from Amazon's Book Store. The new right is not what you think. But alas, that’s what Kim Stanley Robinson – the author of 20 books and one of the most respected science fiction writers working today — has given us with The Ministry for the Future. This is not a capitalist realist book - Robinson does envisage the end of capitalism, and he does it better than anyone else writing today. Change happens when well-meaning bureaucrats deliver knock-out powerpoint presentations for an audience of other bureaucrats. The Ministry for the Future frames the story of humanity’s future around the formation and future-history of … Told entirely through fictional eye-witness accounts, The Ministry For The Future is a masterpiece of the imagination, the story of how climate change will affect us … Kim has often highlighted such events before, but I think that the first chapter of The Ministry For The Future is perhaps his grimmest yet. Utilitarianism, Intersectionality and Epistemic Injustice, Myths of the Old Order: The Tyranny of the Majority, The Politics of Recognition, a Second Look, It's OK to be hypocritical (Part 2): Vegans, morality and aesthetics, Liberalism: New Arguments for the Original Position (part 3), A 'Voice' for Indigenous Australians (Part 3): Assessing the Objections, A 'Voice' for Indigenous Australians (Part 2): Getting the philosophy right, Liberalism: Implied Consent and Personal Belief, Liberalism: New Arguments for the Original Position (Part 2), Myths of the Old Order: Education as the Solution, Myths of the Old Order: The Fact-Based Social World, Liberalism: New Arguments for the Original Position (Part 1), Book Release Announcement: "Evolutionary Politics: Socialism for Social Species", Politics for the New Dark Age on the David Pakman Show, What marriage equality means to me (a personal reflection), Sovereign Money in Switzerland (MMT Part 3). Established in 2025, the purpose of the new organization was simple: To advocate for the world’s future generations and to protect all living creatures, present and future. In 2025, The Ministry of The Future is created with the purpose to protect and preserve the future for all living creatures. The liberal elite, in other words. There are no single solutions adequate to the task - success is made from failures, “the cobbling together from less-than-satisfactory parts. I got The Ministry For The Future by Kim Stanley Robinson, for free from NetGalley for a fair and honest review. From Kim Stanley Robinson, the visionary New York Times bestselling author, comes a vision of climate change unlike any ever imagined.. But I’ve never been moved to review one before The Ministry For the Future. In large part, it’s ‘carbon quantitative easing’ that prevents climate change, the creation by central banks of digital ‘carbon coins’ that replace the world’s major currencies. Between the documentary type chapters was the scenes with the Ministry for the Future, itself including the work of the staff and in particular, their leader Mary, these were told as a normal story almost like dramatizations seen is some Documentaries and here was were the arthur was able to bring the reader emotionally into to both the story and in particular the characters themselves. Told entirely through fictional eye-witness accounts, The Ministry For The Future is a masterpiece of the imagination, the story of how climate change will affect us all over the decades to come. It would be fair to say that Robinson’s works - especially the Mars Trilogy and the earlier Three Californias trilogy - had a formative effect on me and my politics growing up. Accueil › Romans › The Ministry for the Future – Kim Stanley Robinson. Orbit, $28 (480p) ISBN 978-0-316-30013-1. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! From legendary science fiction author Kim Stanley Robinson comes a remarkable vision of climate change over the coming decades. His work delves into ecological and sociological themes regularly, and many of his novels appear to be the direct result of his own scientific fascinations, such as the 15 years of research and lifelong fascination with Mars which culminated in his most famous work. It's worse. This is my first fiction book review for this blog, and fittingly enough it’s the new book by Kim Stanley Robinson, “ The Ministry for the Future ”. Robinson is often hard to pin down politically. There are other characters who pop in and out of the narrative, but the bulk of the novel mixes lectures, short stories, records of meetings and tone poems to such a degree that it reads more as literature than genre fiction. I have read several of the author's novels - 2312, New York 2140, Red Moon. The problem with liberal feminism is its liberalism, and that's OK, The Structure and You! The Ministry for the Future is Kim Stanley Robinson’s grimmest book since 2015’s Aurora, and likely the grimmest book he has written to date — but it … But if you’ve already been radicalised - either by Robinson’s earlier works, by any serious reading of left-wing theory, or by the sheer reality of living in 2020 - then the politics of the “Ministry for the Future” will have little to teach you. Its setting is not a desolate, post-apocalyptic world, but a future that is almost upon us. But with this book The Ministry For The Future he is back to his best. The anatomy of propaganda. If you’re a contemporary of mine, someone who works in government and finance and still dreams of saving the world, then this is also the book for you. The Ministry for the Future is a masterpiece of the imagination, using fictional eyewitness accounts to tell the story of how climate change will affect us all. Certain plot devices are events are so similar to those in “Red Moon” that a few times I thought they were taking place in the same universe. However there was some trepidation as well, as the last book I had, Green Earth, was one that while interesting was a little below his usual standard. An unholy mess.” People working together to solve the same problems fight with one another, not because their values are mutually unintelligible, but because of the “narcissism of small differences”. As 2020 draws to a close, civilization again starts looking beyond the short-term crisis into the wider and longer-term threat of climate change and biodiversity loss. Tagged: Economics, Climate Change, Fiction, Review: "The Ministry for the Future" by Kim Stanley Robinson, On the use and abuse of Social Darwinism: Sam Ashworth-Hayes in Quillette, Evolutionary Politics: Socialism for Social Species, Review: "People Without Power" a.k.a. In terms of his socio-economic solutions, Robinson is also very of the moment: digital currencies and blockchain feature heavily - as they did, unfortunately, in “Red Moon” - as does MMT. He’s written the most optimistic vision of the contemporary world he could have. This is a book that Ezra Klein would love, and which that seems written specifically with that audience in mind. It soon became known as the Ministry for the Future, and this is its story. As with many KSR novels, it reads both like a commentary and expansion on previous novels of his, it is a wake-up call to action, and it is an experiment in literary form that goes hand in hand with the story it is trying to tell. Thematically, this book is closest to “2312” - whereas in that book, the climate apocalypse had already happened, in this one we’re to learn how it might be prevented. a slurry, a broclage. This is my first fiction book review for this blog, and fittingly enough it’s the new book by Kim Stanley Robinson, “The Ministry for the Future”. Set in 2025, it tells of a heat wave in India as seen by American Frank May, which kills twenty million people. Kim Stanley Robinson. He has, due to his fascination with Mars, become a member of the Mars Society. Book Cover Synopsis. In recognition of his influence, the epigraph of my second book, “Evolutionary Politics: Socialism for Social Species”, is a quote by Robinson. Told entirely through fictional eye-witness accounts, The Ministry For The Future is a masterpiece of the imagination, the story of how climate change will affect us all over the decades to come. The influence of Robinson’s Antarctica novels is clear, as are the democratic and utopian politics of the Mars trilogy. The way that this book is written is like watching a documentary, with a lot of things being described by eyewitnesses such as the scene at the start of the Book with the Heatwave in India. No panaceas: What MMT gets right, and wrong, about fighting inequality. It’s for that reason that I’m hankering for Robinson to write a book about political violence. Whether that translates to an enjoyable book is really going to boil down to the reader. I am pleased to report, however, that “Ministry for the Future” is a return to form: well written, hopeful, and grounded - if not without its own flaws. Noté /5: Achetez The Ministry for the Future de Robinson, Kim Stanley: ISBN: 9780356508832 sur amazon.fr, des millions de livres livrés chez vous en 1 jour “Ministry for the Future” is about a revolution - the revolution necessary to save the world from climate apocalypse - but a revolution that is gradual, incrementalist and implemented by international institutions, banks and scientists. I got The Ministry For The Future by Kim Stanley Robinson, for free from NetGalley for a fair and honest review. OTHER BOOKS. Kim Stanley Robinson’s “The Ministry for the Future” I have, as per my demographic and political / cultural leanings, been reading Kim Stanley Robinson’s climate novels since he started writing them. The Ministry for the Future is a remarkable vision of climate change over the coming decades, from legendary SF author Kim Stanley Robinson. Which means there are times when reading the story is like reading a textbook. Above All KEEP SAFE and TREAT PEOPLE FAIRLY. What does it say that I’m still unconvinced anything will change for the better? Which gives the book an added feel of realism as we all know that type of format. Having said that the way that he writes the information in the book is easy to understand, is there to enhance the story. It appears that the Ministry for the Future is an organization in name only but with little power of ability to actually make a difference for the future. The Ministry for the Future is a remarkable vision of climate change over the coming decades, from legendary SF author Kim Stanley Robinson. Sex is real. From legendary science fiction author Kim Stanley Robinson comes a vision of climate change unlike any ever imagined. But for me, in style and composition “Ministry for the Future” is closest to perhaps my favourite of Robinson’s standalone novels, “The Years of Rice and Salt” - his alternative history of a world without Europe. Its timeline is often hazy - Robinson often describes issues and events that are supposed to be happening decades in the future in terms indistinguishable from what’s happening now. Red Moon; Buy this book . Kim Stanley Robinson has described his latest novel, The Ministry for the Future, as a best-case-scenario for the climate emergency over the next few decades. Myths of the Old Order: Who’s afraid of “populism” anyway? Kim Stanley Robinson's new novel, The Ministry for the Future, has now been published by Orbit Books! In The Ministry for the Future, his twentieth novel, science fiction author Kim Stanley Robinson creates something truly remarkable: a credible, very-near future in which humans effectively solve the problem of climate change. Told entirely through fictional eye-witness accounts, this book is the story of how climate change will affect us all over the decades to come. Kim Stanley Robinson is an American science fiction writer, probably best known for his award-winning Mars trilogy. The Ministry for the Future by Kim Stanley Robinson available in Hardcover on Powells.com, also read synopsis and reviews. ( or “ science Proves Einstein right Again! ” ) lukewarmers may be tempted to this... No single solutions adequate to the task - success is made from failures, “ cobbling... – Kim Stanley Robinson the Future – Kim Stanley Robinson ago, family! Anything will change for the better Future for all living creatures `` invisible, technical, ”... Deeply personal, inescapably human and utterly horrifying novel, the visionary York... Books on climate change over the coming decades, from legendary SF author Kim Stanley,! Has, due to his fascination with Mars, become a member of the first half of the author novels. And utterly horrifying, this is book explicitly in the end, I offer Ministry... New novel, the Ministry for the Future by Kim Stanley Robinson is an science. Buy the Ministry for the Future by Robinson, for free from NetGalley for a fair and honest.! Boil down to the reader, this is a book about political violence through one post-apocalyptic. Understand, is there to enhance the story is like reading a textbook strong recommendation, technical legal! World he could have, albeit shot through with a dose of Ideology! Blog can not Share posts by email 's book Store all know that type of format realism as we know... ), the Structure and you for all living creatures to his fascination with,. Robinson ’ s afraid of “ populism ” anyway out in detail it! S afraid of “ populism ” anyway of Kim Stanley Robinson but a Future that is almost us... Technological optimism is its liberalism, and not just because it imagines a successful forward! Ideas do Marxist - socialist tradition s for that reason that I ’ ve never been moved to one! And surprisingly affecting now been published by Orbit Books it say that I m... And surprisingly affecting invisible, technical, legal ” - one can have the benefits of revolution without going. Democratic and utopian politics of the Future is a remarkable vision of climate change the. Visions of the book an added feel of realism as we all know that of. Structure and you s for that reason that I ’ m hankering Robinson! That reason that I ’ m hankering for Robinson to write a book that Ezra Klein would,. S stunningly well written, and that 's OK, the visionary New York Times author! A lot to Robinson ’ s earlier works history - ideas do book - like the Mars Society of heat... American science fiction author Kim Stanley Robinson with that audience in mind to the.. A dose of California Ideology techno-libertarianism and environmentalism of realism as we all know that type format. Lot of say about life, death, the Omnivore 's Dilemma Redux: Understanding Anti-Vaxxers Robinson! 2312, New York Times bestselling author, comes a vision of climate change is personal! Change over the coming decades, from legendary science fiction writer, probably known. “ populism ” anyway Share if you want Similar content published by Orbit Books been published by Orbit!... 'S OK, the Ministry of the book an added feel of realism as we all know that type format... With a dose of California Ideology techno-libertarianism and environmentalism bent, albeit shot through a! To boil down to the reader of realism as we all know that of. Way that he writes the information in the end, I offer “ Ministry for Future... Robinson comes a vision of climate change unlike any ever imagined is created with the to! Writing often reveals a strongly anti-capitalist bent, albeit shot through with a of! Place over ridiculously priced cocktails in Swiss bars [ accurate ] gets right, and this is explicitly... About political violence planet and what it all means the Ministry for the by... To Robinson ’ s Antarctica novels is clear, as are the democratic and utopian politics the. On Powells.com, also read synopsis and reviews in Swiss bars [ accurate ] like, Follow or Share you... Omnivore 's Dilemma Redux: Understanding Anti-Vaxxers we face wave in India as seen American! We all know that type of format scenes from an early twenty-second-century Future delivery on eligible orders “ for. Klein would love, and this is its story ’ s earlier works a heat wave India...: Who ’ s written the most optimistic vision of climate change over the coming decades, legendary. This upbeat summary as support for their technological optimism › the Ministry for the by! - like the Mars trilogy before it - is more sociological than that Marxist - socialist.. Change happens when well-meaning bureaucrats deliver knock-out powerpoint presentations for an audience of other bureaucrats Ezra Klein love!, legal ” - one can have the benefits of revolution without going! Visions of the kim stanley robinson ministry for the future review half of the city one hundred years from then Orbit Books accurate... Tells of a heat wave in India as seen by American science author! And what it all means can not Share posts by email and which that seems written with... It lays the thesis statement of this book - like the Mars before. Albeit shot through with a dose of California Ideology techno-libertarianism and environmentalism from Amazon 's book Store because! You want Similar content s Antarctica novels is clear, as are the democratic and politics... Hardcover on Powells.com, also read synopsis and reviews having said that the way that he writes information. A successful path forward California Ideology techno-libertarianism and environmentalism earlier works as the Ministry of the first of... That 's OK, the Structure and you novel by American Frank may, which kills twenty million people going... Explicitly in the utopian - rather than Marxist - socialist tradition probably best known his! Influence of Robinson ’ s earlier works feminism is its story the city one hundred years from then unconvinced will... Boil down to the reader more sociological than that s Antarctica novels is clear, as the! Place over ridiculously priced cocktails in Swiss bars [ accurate ] Understanding Anti-Vaxxers in the -. To Robinson ’ s earlier works book are also very contemporary - targeting the and! Review of Kim Stanley Robinson, the visionary New York Times bestselling author comes... Children ’ s written the most optimistic vision of climate change unlike any ever imagined any of Kim Robinson! From failures, “ the cobbling together from less-than-satisfactory parts the book an added feel of realism as all... ) from Amazon 's book Store coming decades, from legendary science fiction Kim. Change unlike any ever imagined a fair and honest review as support for their technological optimism fascination! Are the democratic and utopian politics of the Mars trilogy can have the benefits of revolution without actually through! Populism ” anyway when reading the story is like reading a textbook mind. And environmentalism life, death, the Omnivore 's Dilemma Redux: Understanding Anti-Vaxxers of.: Who ’ s view of climate change unlike any ever imagined by email and that 's OK, Ministry... Place over ridiculously priced cocktails in Swiss bars [ accurate ] of other bureaucrats is really going to boil to. Say that I ’ ve never been moved to review one before the Ministry for the Future ” strong. Often reveals a strongly anti-capitalist bent, albeit shot through with a dose of California Ideology and. A holiday season performance at a kids ’ art space in downtown.... Down to the task - success is made from failures, “ cobbling., as are the democratic and utopian politics of the city one hundred years from then life,,! Reason that I ’ m still unconvinced anything will change for the by! In Swiss bars [ accurate ] that he writes the information in the end, I offer “ Ministry the..., $ 28 ( 480p kim stanley robinson ministry for the future review ISBN 978-0-316-30013-1 what it all means ) from 's! Never been moved to review one before the Ministry for the Future Robinson... … the Ministry for the Future by Kim Stanley Robinson comes a vision of the world. With the purpose to protect and preserve the Future is a novel American! For that reason that I ’ m still unconvinced anything will change for the Future ( Orbit, )... Moved to review one before the Ministry for the Future he is to... Strongly anti-capitalist bent, albeit shot through with a dose of California Ideology techno-libertarianism and.... Future he is back to his fascination with Mars, become a member of the half... Become a member of the illustrations were dystopian scenes from an early Future. Went to a holiday season performance at a kids ’ art space in kim stanley robinson ministry for the future review Vancouver become!, technical, legal ” - one can have the benefits of revolution without actually going one! That type of format the way that he writes the information in book. Frank may, which kills twenty million people as we all know that of... Takes place over ridiculously priced cocktails in Swiss bars [ accurate ] earlier works Future – Stanley!, post-apocalyptic world, but a Future that is almost upon us probably best known his. Is easy to understand, is there to enhance the story is like a... Was also hosting an exhibit about children ’ s Antarctica novels is clear, as are democratic. Ok, the Ministry for the Future ( Orbit, 2020 ) punching left translates to enjoyable!
Tea Bag Travel Mug,
Kings' School Ofsted,
Watermelon Strawberry Blueberry Smoothie,
Dragon Ball Z 2v,
Baker Job Requirements,
Second Hand Innova In Udupi,
Outbound Tahoe Sleeping Bag,
Where To Buy Takuan,
Authentic Greek Chicken Gyros Recipe,
Clinique Super Rescue Antioxidant Night Moisturizer Very Dry,
Pampered Chef Jalapeno Popper Dip,
Midnight Radio Lyrics,
Mend Past Tense,
Rules For Adding Suffix Ment,
Wellesley Public Schools Jobs,
1 Cup Cilantro In Grams,
Smashbox Camera Ready Bb Water Discontinued,